法医学杂志

法医学杂志 ›› 2006, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (2): 144-146.

• 论文 • 上一篇    下一篇

《道路交通事故受伤人员伤残评定》中精神伤残程度司法鉴定相关问题探讨

韩卫;顾珊智;陈腾;贾小俤;   

  1. 西安交通大学医学院法医系,西安交通大学医学院法医系,西安交通大学医学院法医系,西安交通大学医学院法医系 陕西西安710061,陕西西安710061,陕西西安710061,陕西西安710061
  • 发布日期:2006-04-25 出版日期:2006-04-28

A Debate About Mental Disability Expertise of the Disability Evaluation Criteria of Traffic Accident Injurious

HAN WEI, GU SHAN-ZHI, CHEN TENG, JIA XIAO-DI (DEPARTMENT OF FORENSIC SCIENCE, MEDICAL COLLEGE, XI′AN JIAO TONG UNIVERSITY, XI′AN 710061,CHINA)   

  • Online:2006-04-25 Published:2006-04-28

被引次数

7

摘要： 在法医精神病学鉴定实践中,精神伤残的评定越来越多。现行《道路交通事故受伤人员伤残评定》标准中关于精神伤残评定的相关条款过于笼统,可操作性差,常因认识不一致而产生歧义。本文结合典型案例主要从三个方面对精神伤残司法鉴定中常见问题进行探讨:(1)在评定智力缺损程度时,应结合伤前智商进行评定;(2)精神伤残评定的时间应在医疗终结后一年;(3)精神伤残评定中应引入量表进行客观评价。

关键词: 精神伤残, 精神鉴定, 道路交通事故

Abstract: In recent years, mental disability estimation are more than ever in the practice of forensic psychiatric expertise. The standards about mental disability estimation in the Disability Evaluation Criteria of Traffic Accident Injury are ambiguous and difficult to operate, it cause to different understanding in one case. This article discuss some common questions through 3 aspects in mental disability expertise according to some typical cases, there are the first, we should compare the IQ score before and after injurious in intelligence estimate. The second, the mental disability estimation should be done at least one year after the end of medicine treatment. The third, mental estimate scale should be used in mental disability estimation.

Key words: mental disability, psychiatric expertise, traffic accident