Application of Diatoms Quantitative Analysis in the Diagnosis of Drowning

doi:10.12116/j.issn.1004-5619.2021.410707

Abstract

Abstract: Objective

To retrospectively analyze diatom test cases of corpses in water and discuss the value of quantitative analysis of diatoms in the diagnosis of drowning.

Methods

A total of 490 cases of water-related death were collected. They were divided into drowning group and postmortem immersion group according to the cause of death. Diatoms in lung, liver, kidney tissue and water sample were analyzed quantitatively by microwave digestion-vacuum filtration-automated scanning electron microscopy （MD-VF-Auto SEM） method. The ratios of content of diatoms in lung tissue and water sample （C_L/C_D） were calculated.

Results

The results of diatom test for three organs （lung, liver and kidney） were all positive in 400 cases （85.5%）; the content of diatom in lung, liver, kidney tissues, and water samples of drowning group were （113 235.9±317 868.1）, （26.7±75.6）, （23.3±52.2） and （12 113.3±21 760.0） cells/10 g, respectively; the species of diatom were （7.5±2.8）, （2.6±1.9）, （2.9±2.1） and （8.9±3.0） types, respectively; the C_L/C_D of drowning group and postmortem immersion group were （100.6±830.7） and （0.3±0.4）, respectively.

Conclusion

Quantitative analysis of diatoms can provide supportive evidence for the diagnosis of drowning, and the parameter C_L/C_D can be introduced into the analysis to make a more accurate diagnosis of drowning.

Key words: forensic pathology, drowning, diatom test, quantitative analysis, microwave digestion-vacuum filtration-automated scanning electron microscopy method

CLC Number:

DF795.1

Yu-kun DU, Tian-ye ZHANG, Jing-jian LIU, Chao LIU, Xiao-dong KANG, Dong-yun ZHENG, He SHI, Qu-yi XU, Kai-jun MA, Jian ZHAO. Application of Diatoms Quantitative Analysis in the Diagnosis of Drowning[J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2022, 38(1): 110-113.

Add to citation manager EndNote|Ris|BibTeX

URL: http://www.fyxzz.cn/EN/10.12116/j.issn.1004-5619.2021.410707

http://www.fyxzz.cn/EN/Y2022/V38/I1/110

Figures/Tables 2

Tab. 1 The CL/CD between drowning group and postmortem immersion group

组别	例数	C_L/C_D值
组别	例数	$x ˉ$ ±s	中位数	≤1	>1~<2	≥2
合计	405	-	-	128	31	246
溺死	390	100.6±830.7^1）	4.9	115	29	246
死后入水	15	0.3±0.4	0.3	13	2	0

Tab. 1 The CL/CD between drowning group and postmortem immersion group

组别	例数	C_L/C_D值
组别	例数	$x ˉ$ ±s	中位数	≤1	>1~<2	≥2
合计	405	-	-	128	31	246
溺死	390	100.6±830.7^1）	4.9	115	29	246
死后入水	15	0.3±0.4	0.3	13	2	0

Tab. 2 The CL/CD of drowning group

水样中硅藻含量/（个·10 g^-1）	例数	C_L/C_D值
<100	23	570.3±1 844.8
100~1 000	56	349.3±1 816.2
1 000~10 000	203	27.2±87.9
>10 000	108	9.4±18.7

References 23

1	REVENSTORF V. Der nachweis der aspirierten ertränkungsflüssigkeit als kriterium des todes durch ertrinken[J]. Vierteljahresschr Gerichtl Med，1904，28：274-279.
2	AUER A， MÖTTÖNEN M. Diatoms and drowning[J]. Zeitschrift Für Rechtsmedizin，1988，101（2）：87-98. doi：10.1007/BF00200290 .
3	HÜRLIMANN J， FEER P， ELBER F， et al. Diatom detection in the diagnosis of death by drowning[J]. Int J Legal Med，2000，114（1/2）：6-14. doi：10.1007/s004149900122 .
4	PIETTE M H， DE LETTER E A. Drowning： Still a difficult autopsy diagnosis[J]. Forensic Sci Int，2006，163（1/2）：1-9. doi：10.1016/j.forsciint.2004.10.027 .
5	赵虎，刘超. 高级法医学[M]. 3版. 郑州：郑州大学出版社，2021：228-234.
	ZHAO H， LIU C. Advanced forensic medicine[M]. 3rd ed. Zhengzhou： Zhengzhou University Press，2021：228-234.
6	SHEN X， LIU Y， XIAO C， et al. Analysis of false-positive results of diatom test in the diagnosis of drowning-would not be an impediment[J]. Int J Legal Med，2019，133（6）：1819-1824. doi：10.1007/s00414-019-02021-4 .
7	POLLANEN M S， CHEUNG C， CHIASSON D A. The diagnostic value of the diatom test for drowning， I. Utility： A retrospective analysis of 771 cases of drowning in Ontario， Canada[J]. J Forensic Sci，1997，42（2）：281-285.
8	FOGED N. Diatoms and drowning - Once more[J]. Forensic Sci Int，1983，21（2）：153-159. doi：10.1016/0379-0738（83）90104-4 .
9	MUELLER B. On the problem of the occurrence of diatoms in the organs of cadavers not having lain in the water[J]. Dtsch Z Gesamte Gerichtl Med，1963，54：267-272.
10	SCHELLMANN B， SPERL W. Detection of diatoms in bone marrow （femur） of nondrowned[J]. Z Rechtsmed，1979，83（4）：319-324. doi：10.1007/bf01882178 .
11	PORAWSKI R. Investigations on the occurrence of diatoms in organs in death from various causes[J]. J Forensic Med，1966，13（4）：134-137.
12	DETTMEYER R B， VERHOFF M A， SCHÜTZ H F. Forensic medicine： Fundamentals and perspectives[M]. Berlin Heidelberg： Springer, 2014.
13	ZHAO J， ZHANG P P， XUE Y， et al. Correlation analysis of diatom content in the organs and drowning mediums for the drowning death cases[J]. Aust J Forensic Sci，2021，53（2）：191-198. doi：10.1080/00450618.2019.1682667 .
14	ZHAO J， LIU C， BARDEESI A S A， et al. The diagnostic value of quantitative assessment of diatom test for drowning： An analysis of 128 water-related death cases using microwave digestion-vacuum filtration-automated scanning electron microscopy[J]. J Forensic Sci，2017，62（6）：1638-1642. doi：10.1111/1556-4029.13455 .
15	LI Z G， WU B， CHENG X， et al. Evaluation of L/D ratio in a water-related case for the differentiation between drowning and postmortem immersion[J]. Forensic Sci Int Synergy，2019，1：68-70. doi：10.1016/j.fsisyn.2019.04.001 .
16	ZHAO J， MA Y B， LIU C， et al. A quantitative comparison analysis of diatoms in the lung tissues and the drowning medium as an indicator of drowning[J]. J Forensic Leg Med，2016，42：75-78. doi：10.1016/j.jflm.2016.05.021 .
17	赵建，罗银洲，王玉仲，等. 肺组织硅藻定量分析在实验动物溺死诊断中的应用[J]. 法医学杂志，2019，35（6）：706-709. doi：10.12116/j.issn.1004-5619.2019.06.011 .
	ZHAO J， LUO Y Z， WANG Y Z， et al. Application of quantitative analysis of diatoms in lung tissue for the diagnosis of drowning of experimental animals[J]. Fayixue Zazhi，2019，35（6）：706-709.
18	广州市刑事科学技术研究所、公安部物证鉴定中心. 法庭科学硅藻检验技术规范微波消解-真空抽滤-显微镜法： [S]. 北京: 中国标准出版社, 2020.
	Guangzhou Forensic Science Institute, Institute of Forensic Science, Ministry of Public Security. Forensic sciences - Technical specifications for diatom inspection - Microwave digestion-vacuum filtration - microscopy： [S]. Beijing: China Standards Publishing Press, 2020.
19	ZHAO J， LIU C， HU S， et al. Microwave digestion - vacuum filtration - automated scanning electron microscopy as a sensitive method for forensic diatom test[J]. Int J Legal Med，2013，127（2）：459-463. doi：10.1007/s00414-012-0756-9 .
20	苏会芳，刘超，胡孙林，等. 微波消解-扫描电镜联用法在溺死诊断中的应用[J]. 中国法医学杂志，2012，27（2）：97-100，107. doi：10.13618/j.issn.1001-5728.2012.02.002 .
	SU H F， LIU C， HU S L， et al. The application of microwave digestion technique and scanning electron microscopy to diatom test in diagnosis of drowning[J]. Zhongguo Fayixue Zazhi，2012，27（2）：97-100，107.
21	LUNETTA P， MIETTINEN A， SPILLING K， et al. False-positive diatom test： A real challenge? A post-mortem study using standardized protocols[J]. Leg Med，2013，15（5）：229-234. doi：10.1016/j.legalmed.2013.03.002 .
22	ZHANG P， KANG X， ZHANG S， et al. The length and width of diatoms in drowning cases as the evidence of diatoms penetrating the alveoli-capillary barrier[J]. Int J Legal Med，2020，134（3）：1037-1042. doi：10.1007/s00414-019-02164-4 .
23	LUNETTA P， PENTTILÄ A， HÄLLFORS G. Scanning and transmission electron microscopical evidence of the capacity of diatoms to penetrate the alveolo-capillary barrier in drowning[J]. Int J Legal Med，1998，111（5）：229-237. doi：10.1007/s004140050159 .

[1]	Jie YANG, Yi-lei HU, Jin-ming WANG, Zheng-dong LI. Analysis of the Injury Mechanism of Traumatic Craniocerebral Injury from Falls Based on Finite Element Simulation [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2026, 42(1): 1-7.
[2]	Qiong JIA, Kai-jun JIN, Shi-qi LIU, Yi-meng ZHANG, Yun-le MENG, Hao NIE, Sheng HU, Fan YANG, Xing-chun ZHAO, Jian YE. Research Progress on the Methodological System for Decomposition Stage Classification in Forensic Medicine [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2026, 42(1): 34-42.
[3]	Xin NIU, Zhe CAO. Forensic Significance of Mesenteric Injury in Child Abuse Cases [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2026, 42(1): 43-48.
[4]	Zhen WANG, Tai-qi ZANG. Comprehensive Identification of the Vulnerant by Examining Marks on Clothing and Bodies Combining with Trace Comparison： A Case Report [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2026, 42(1): 69-72.
[5]	Jia MENG, Ling-yu LI, Wu-lin HUANG, Tong ZHOU, Meng-qin ZOU, Jian-wei PENG, Bo LI, Xin HUANG, Qing-bo ZHANG. Multidisciplinary Identification in a Hit-and-Run Traffic Accident： A Case Report [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2026, 42(1): 73-76.
[6]	Cong-da SHEN, Shi-fan WU, Yi WU, Wen-dong MAO, Xiang-tao MA. Fatal Rupture of the Abdominal Aorta Caused by Trampling： A Case Report [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2026, 42(1): 77-78.
[7]	Jun-jiang CHEN, Lan-jiang LI, Pu-ping LEI, Shang-wen WANG, Xin-biao LIAO, Li-fang CHEN, Huan ZHANG. Forensic Identification of a Fatality from Confined Container Deflagration Complicated by Tertiary Blast Injury： A Case Report [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2026, 42(1): 79-83.
[8]	Jian YE, Yong-liang HU, Ya-ling XIE, Yu CAI, Wen-hao LI. Medical Damage Identification of CT Guided Pulmonary Nodule Localization Needle Escapes to the Left Ventricle： A Case Report [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2026, 42(1): 83-86.
[9]	Ning-guo LIU. Innovative Development and Future Prospects in Forensic Pathology [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2025, 41(6): 517-530.
[10]	Yu-mei WANG. Postmortem Submersion Interval Estimation of Bodies Recovered from the Jingzhou Reach of the Yangtze River by Aquatic Decomposition Score [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2025, 41(6): 552-558.
[11]	Jin-xuan YANG, Dong-an TIAN, Xin-yu TANG, Zhan-ying ZHAO, Xi-yue JING, Dong-mei WANG, Xiao-fei TIAN. The Role of Iron Dysregulation in White Matter Injury Induced by Carbon Mono- xide Poisoning [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2025, 41(6): 545-551.
[12]	Li-liang LI, Jian-hua ZHANG, Feng CHEN, Rui ZHAO, Ya-dong GUO, Zhen-yuan WANG, Yi-wu ZHOU, Da-wei GUAN, Bin CONG. Expert Consensus on Cause of Death Determinations in Antipsychotics-Related Deaths with Negative Autopsy Findings [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2025, 41(6): 537-544.
[13]	Ji CHEN, Yu-rong ZHAO, Xin HUANG, Yi-ling QU, Yan-fang LU, Yu XING, Han ZHANG, Jian-ye ZENG, Shi-lin LI, Su-hua ZHANG. Effect of Temperature on Microbial Succession in Different Tissues of Cadavers and Estimation of Postmortem Interval [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2025, 41(5): 456-467.
[14]	Xiao-feng ZHANG, Lin CHEN, Xiao-hui CHEN, Jian ZHAO, Tian-chun LIN, Dang-en GU, Feng WANG, Zhi-yong LIU, Shi-yun MENG, Xing-yi YANG, Qu-yi XU. Diagnosis of Drowning by qPCR Detection of Plankton DNA in Cardiac Blood of Cadavers [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2025, 41(5): 477-481.
[15]	Hao-jie QIN, Chen MO, Hong-wei LI, Zhi-jiang LIU, Zhe ZHENG. Role of Ferroptosis in Paraquat-Induced Acute Lung Injury in Mice [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2025, 41(5): 494-501.