Journal of Forensic Medicine ›› 2024, Vol. 40 ›› Issue (2): 128-134.DOI: 10.12116/j.issn.1004-5619.2023.231209
Special Issue: 法医人类学年龄推断专题
Previous Articles Next Articles
Xuan WEI1(
), Yu-shan CHEN1, Jie DING2, Chang-xing SONG2, Jun-jing WANG2, Zhao PENG3, Zhen-hua DENG1, Xu YI2(
), Fei FAN1(
)
Received:2023-12-26
Online:2024-06-07
Published:2024-04-25
Contact:
Xu YI, Fei FAN
CLC Number:
Xuan WEI, Yu-shan CHEN, Jie DING, Chang-xing SONG, Jun-jing WANG, Zhao PENG, Zhen-hua DENG, Xu YI, Fei FAN. Age Estimation by Machine Learning and CT-Multiplanar Reformation of Cranial Sutures in Northern Chinese Han Adults[J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2024, 40(2): 128-134.
Add to citation manager EndNote|Ris|BibTeX
URL: http://www.fyxzz.cn/EN/10.12116/j.issn.1004-5619.2023.231209
| 实际年龄/岁 | 男性 | 女性 | 合计 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 合计 | 57 | 75 | 132 |
| 29.00~<40.00 | 9 | 11 | 20 |
| 40.00~<50.00 | 12 | 16 | 28 |
| 50.00~<60.00 | 12 | 16 | 28 |
| 60.00~<70.00 | 13 | 21 | 34 |
| 70.00~80.00 | 11 | 11 | 22 |
Tab. 1 Age and sex distribution of 132 samples
| 实际年龄/岁 | 男性 | 女性 | 合计 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 合计 | 57 | 75 | 132 |
| 29.00~<40.00 | 9 | 11 | 20 |
| 40.00~<50.00 | 12 | 16 | 28 |
| 50.00~<60.00 | 12 | 16 | 28 |
| 60.00~<70.00 | 13 | 21 | 34 |
| 70.00~80.00 | 11 | 11 | 22 |
| 分级 | 描述 | 示意图 | 图像(以矢状缝为例) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 等级1 | 颅缝未闭合 | ![]() | ![]() |
| 等级2 | 颅内缝开始闭合 | ![]() | ![]() |
| 等级3 | 颅内缝完全闭合 | ![]() | ![]() |
| 等级4 | 颅缝小部分闭合(<50%) | ![]() | ![]() |
| 等级5 | 颅缝大部分闭合(>50%) | ![]() | ![]() |
| 等级6 | 颅缝完全闭合,可见残留闭合线 | ![]() | ![]() |
| 等级7 | 颅缝完全闭合,闭合线消失 | ![]() | ![]() |
Tab. 2 Schematic diagram of cranial suture closure grades
| 分级 | 描述 | 示意图 | 图像(以矢状缝为例) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 等级1 | 颅缝未闭合 | ![]() | ![]() |
| 等级2 | 颅内缝开始闭合 | ![]() | ![]() |
| 等级3 | 颅内缝完全闭合 | ![]() | ![]() |
| 等级4 | 颅缝小部分闭合(<50%) | ![]() | ![]() |
| 等级5 | 颅缝大部分闭合(>50%) | ![]() | ![]() |
| 等级6 | 颅缝完全闭合,可见残留闭合线 | ![]() | ![]() |
| 等级7 | 颅缝完全闭合,闭合线消失 | ![]() | ![]() |
| 模型 | 参数 |
|---|---|
| 梯度提升回归 | n_estimators=20,min_samples_split=100,max_depth=1,subsample=1 |
| 支持向量回归 | kernel=rbf,C=10,gamma=0.01 |
| 决策树回归 | max_depth=1,min_samples_leaf=1,min_samples_split=2 |
| 贝叶斯岭回归 | max_iter=1,tol=0.0001 |
Tab. 3 Parameters of 4 machine learning models
| 模型 | 参数 |
|---|---|
| 梯度提升回归 | n_estimators=20,min_samples_split=100,max_depth=1,subsample=1 |
| 支持向量回归 | kernel=rbf,C=10,gamma=0.01 |
| 决策树回归 | max_depth=1,min_samples_leaf=1,min_samples_split=2 |
| 贝叶斯岭回归 | max_iter=1,tol=0.0001 |
| 颅缝 | 等级/(n=132, | 等级≥6 | ρ值1) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 最小年龄/岁 | 例数 | |||
| 矢状缝 | 4.40±1.49 | 45 | 17 | 0.501 |
| 左侧人字缝 | 3.50±1.372) | - | 0 | 0.360 |
| 右侧人字缝 | 3.47±1.462) | 59 | 1 | 0.398 |
| 左侧冠状缝 | 3.93±1.302)3)4) | 56 | 4 | 0.463 |
| 右侧冠状缝 | 3.79±1.332)3)4)5) | 62 | 1 | 0.463 |
Tab. 4 Distribution of closure grade of each cranial suture
| 颅缝 | 等级/(n=132, | 等级≥6 | ρ值1) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 最小年龄/岁 | 例数 | |||
| 矢状缝 | 4.40±1.49 | 45 | 17 | 0.501 |
| 左侧人字缝 | 3.50±1.372) | - | 0 | 0.360 |
| 右侧人字缝 | 3.47±1.462) | 59 | 1 | 0.398 |
| 左侧冠状缝 | 3.93±1.302)3)4) | 56 | 4 | 0.463 |
| 右侧冠状缝 | 3.79±1.332)3)4)5) | 62 | 1 | 0.463 |
| 编号 | 模型 | r | ME/岁 | MAE/岁 | RMSE/岁 | AE<10%1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 线性回归(y=4.571 x1-1.906 x2-0.112 x3+0.575 x4+2.343 x5+32.247) | 0.530 | 3.668 | 10.164 | 12.605 | 62.96%(17/27) |
| 2 | 梯度提升回归 | 0.592 | 3.346 | 9.843 | 12.259 | 62.96%(17/27) |
| 3 | 支持向量回归 | 0.622 | 3.075 | 9.542 | 11.915 | 66.67%(18/27) |
| 4 | 决策树回归 | 0.546 | 3.737 | 9.648 | 12.450 | 62.96%(17/27) |
| 5 | 贝叶斯岭回归 | 0.568 | 3.427 | 9.877 | 12.366 | 55.56%(15/27) |
| 6 | 线性回归(y=2.765 x1+1.996 x2+4.033 x4+13.235)2) | 0.580 | -3.845 | 10.211 | 12.157 | 59.26%(16/27) |
| 7 | 线性回归(y=11.02 x6+17.19)3) | 0.598 | 0.072 | 11.104 | 13.949 | 55.56%(15/27) |
Tab. 5 Accuracy of each cranial suture age estimation models in the test set
| 编号 | 模型 | r | ME/岁 | MAE/岁 | RMSE/岁 | AE<10%1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 线性回归(y=4.571 x1-1.906 x2-0.112 x3+0.575 x4+2.343 x5+32.247) | 0.530 | 3.668 | 10.164 | 12.605 | 62.96%(17/27) |
| 2 | 梯度提升回归 | 0.592 | 3.346 | 9.843 | 12.259 | 62.96%(17/27) |
| 3 | 支持向量回归 | 0.622 | 3.075 | 9.542 | 11.915 | 66.67%(18/27) |
| 4 | 决策树回归 | 0.546 | 3.737 | 9.648 | 12.450 | 62.96%(17/27) |
| 5 | 贝叶斯岭回归 | 0.568 | 3.427 | 9.877 | 12.366 | 55.56%(15/27) |
| 6 | 线性回归(y=2.765 x1+1.996 x2+4.033 x4+13.235)2) | 0.580 | -3.845 | 10.211 | 12.157 | 59.26%(16/27) |
| 7 | 线性回归(y=11.02 x6+17.19)3) | 0.598 | 0.072 | 11.104 | 13.949 | 55.56%(15/27) |
| 1 | TODD T W, LYON JR D W. Endocranial suture closure. Its progress and age relationship. Part Ⅰ. — Adult males of white stock[J]. Am J Phys Anthropol,1924,7(3):325-384. doi:10.1002/ajpa.1330070320 . |
| 2 | TODD T W, LYON JR D W. Cranial suture closure. Its progress and age relationship. Part Ⅱ. — Ectocranial closure in adult males of white stock[J]. Am J Phys Anthropol,1925,8(1):23-45. doi:10.1002/ajpa.1330080103 . |
| 3 | MEINDL R S, LOVEJOY C O. Ectocranial suture closure: A revised method for the determination of skeletal age at death based on the lateral-anterior sutures[J]. Am J Phys Anthropol,1985,68(1):57-66. doi:10.1002/ajpa.1330680106 . |
| 4 | 范飞,占梦军,戴鑫华,等. 影像学方法推断成人年龄研究进展[J].法医学杂志,2020,36(5):605-613. doi:10.12116/j.issn.1004-5619.2020.05.002 . |
| FAN F, ZHAN M J, DAI X H, et al. Research progress of adult age determination with imaging methods[J]. Fayixue Zazhi,2020,36(5):605-613. | |
| 5 | OBERT M, SCHULTE-GEERS C, SCHILLING R L, et al. High-resolution flat-panel volumetric CT images show no correlation between human age and sagittal suture obliteration — Independent of sex[J]. Forensic Sci Int,2010,200(1/2/3):180.e1-180.e12. doi:10.1016/j.forsciint.2010.04.006 . |
| 6 | NIKOLOVA S, TONEVA D, GEORGIEV I, et al. Sagittal suture maturation: Morphological reorganization, relation to aging, and reliability as an age-at-death indicator[J]. Am J Phys Anthropol,2019,169(1):78-92. doi:10.1002/ajpa.23810 . |
| 7 | HARTH S, OBERT M, RAMSTHALER F, et al. Estimating age by assessing the ossification degree of cranial sutures with the aid of flat-panel-CT[J]. Leg Med (Tokyo),2009,11(S1):186-189. doi:10 . |
| 1016/j.legalmed.2009.01.091. | |
| 8 | BOYD K L, VILLA C, LYNNERUP N. The use of CT scans in estimating age at death by examining the extent of ectocranial suture closure[J]. J Forensic Sci,2015,60(2):363-369. doi:10.1111/1556-4029.12683 . |
| 9 | BARSZCZ M, WOŹNIAK K. Complete sagittal suture closure evaluation based on post mortem computed tomography[J]. Leg Med (Tokyo),2021,52:101907. doi:10.1016/j.legalmed.2021.101907 . |
| 10 | 莫世泰,张文光,雷绍伯,等. 中国人颅骨缝的变化与年龄关系[J].人类学学报,1989,8(2):131-138. |
| MO S T, ZHANG W G, LEI S B, et al. The relation between the age and changes in Chinese skull suture[J]. Renleixue Xuebao,1989,8(2):131-138. | |
| 11 | FAN F, TU M, LI R, et al. Age estimation by multidetector computed tomography of cranial sutures in Chinese male adults[J]. Am J Phys Anthropol,2020,171(3):550-558. doi:10.1002/ajpa.23998 . |
| 12 | CHIBA F, MAKINO Y, MOTOMURA A, et al. Age estimation by multidetector CT images of the sagittal suture[J]. Int J Legal Med,2013,127(5):1005-1011. doi:10.1007/s00414-013-0883-y . |
| 13 | 裘诗文,涂梦,范飞,等. 应用颅缝薄层CT扫描推断汉族成人年龄[J].法医学杂志,2020,36(4):507-513. doi:10.12116/j.issn.1004-5619.2020.04.015 . |
| QIU S W, TU M, FAN F, et al. Age estimation in Han adults by thin-layer CT scan of cranial sutures[J]. Fayixue Zazhi,2020,36(4):507-513. | |
| 14 | 印国樑. 颅内外骨缝推断年龄的探讨[J].中国法医学杂志,1987,2(4):214-216. doi:10.13618/j.issn.1001-5728.1987.04.008 . |
| YIN G L. A study of the ectocranial and endocranial suture closure for the age estimation[J]. Zhongguo Fayixue Zazhi,1987,2(4):214-216. | |
| 15 | LI J, CHEN Z, ZHONG W, et al. A study of 285 cases of cranial vault suture closure in Chinese adults[J]. Surg Radiol Anat,2022,44(3):361-368. doi:10.1007/s00276-021-02854-y . |
| 16 | RUENGDIT S, PRASITWATTANASEREE S, ME-KJAIDEE K, et al. Age estimation approaches using cranial suture closure: A validation study on a Thai population[J]. J Forensic Leg Med,2018,53:79-86. doi:10.1016/j.jflm.2017.11.009 . |
| 17 | FAN F, DONG X, WU X, et al. An evaluation of statistical models for age estimation and the assessment of the 18-year threshold using conventional pelvic radiographs[J]. Forensic Sci Int,2020,314:110350. doi:10.1016/j.forsciint.2020.110350 . |
| 18 | XU C, QU H, WANG G, et al. A novel strategy for forensic age prediction by DNA methylation and support vector regression model[J]. Sci Rep,2015,5:17788. doi:10.1038/srep17788 . |
| 19 | VELEMÍNSKÁ J, PILNÝ A, CEPEK M, et al. Dental age estimation and different predictive ability of various tooth types in the Czech population: Data mining methods[J]. Anthropol Anz,2013,70(3):331-345. doi:10.1127/0003-5548/2013/0311 . |
| 20 | ŠTEPANOVSKÝ M, IBROVÁ A, BUK Z, et al. Novel age estimation model based on development of permanent teeth compared with classical approach and other modern data mining methods[J]. Forensic Sci Int,2017,279:72-82. doi:10.1016/j.forsciint.2017.08.005 . |
| 21 | MEINL A, HUBER C D, TANGL S, et al. Comparison of the validity of three dental methods for the estimation of age at death[J]. Forensic Sci Int,2008,178(2/3):96-105. doi:10.1016/j.forsciint.2008.02.008 . |
| 22 | LIVERSIDGE H M, SMITH B H, MABER M. Bias and accuracy of age estimation using developing teeth in 946 children[J]. Am J Phys Anthropol,2010,143(4):545-554. doi:10.1002/ajpa.21349 . |
| 23 | AYKROYD R G, LUCY D, POLLARD A M, et al. Technical note: Regression analysis in adult age estimation[J]. Am J Phys Anthropol,1997,104(2):259-265. doi:10.1002/(SICI)1096-8644(199710)104:2<259::AID-AJPA11>3.0.CO;2-Z . |
| 24 | TANGMOSE S, THEVISSEN P, LYNNERUP N, et al. Age estimation in the living: Transition analysis on developing third molars[J]. Forensic Sci Int,2015,257:512.e1-512.e7. doi:10.1016/j.forsciint.2015.07.049 . |
| [1] | Run-ting DOU, Shun CHENG, Xin ZHOU, Xing YE, Zhi-min WANG, Guang-hui HONG, Qi ZHANG, Qing XIA, Yi-wen SHEN. Machine Learning Model Based on Structured Injury Features for Knee Mobility Discriminations after Traumatic Injury [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2026, 42(1): 8-16. |
| [2] | . Precision Identification from a Multi-omics Perspective: Current Status, Challenges, and Prospects in Forensic Genetics ZHU Bo-feng [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2025, 41(5): 421-440. |
| [3] | Hou-ying ZOU, Yin-lei LEI, Ruo-cheng XIA, Yan SHI, Cheng-tao LI. Exploring Microbial Detection of Psychoactive Substances in Wastewater Based on Micobiome Analysis [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2025, 41(5): 468-476. |
| [4] | Zi-wen GUO, Tian-yu QIU, Yue CAO. Rapid Identification of Etomidate and Its Structural Analogues Based on Surface-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy and Machine Learning [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2025, 41(4): 364-370. |
| [5] | Hui-ming ZHOU, Dan-yang LI, Lei WAN, Tai-ang LIU, Yuan-zhe LI, Mao-wen WANG, Ya-hui WANG. Dual-Channel Shoulder Joint X-ray Bone Age Estimation in Chinese Han Adolescents Based on the Fusion of Segmentation Labels and Original Images [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2025, 41(3): 208-216. |
| [6] | Dan-yang LI, Hui-ming ZHOU, Lei WAN, Tai-ang LIU, Yuan-zhe LI, Mao-wen WANG, Ya-hui WANG. Bone Age Estimation of Chinese Han Adolescents’s and Children’s Elbow Joint X-rays Based on Multiple Deep Convolutional Neural Network Models [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2025, 41(1): 48-58. |
| [7] | Yan-jie DING, Xiao ZHANG, Wen-li SHI, Zi-yi LI, Wei WANG, Shi-lin ZHANG, Gen-jie YANG, A-ji GUO, Bo JIN. Estimate the Age of Han Adult Based on the Pulp Chamber Volume and Pulp Dentinal Index of Right First Molars Using Oral and Maxillofacial CBCT [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2025, 41(1): 59-65. |
| [8] | Zhi-lu ZHOU, Dong-fei ZHANG, Jie-min CHEN, Ya-hui WANG, Hong-xia HAO, Tai-ang LIU, Yu-heng HE, Ding-nian LONG, Rui-jue LIU, Lei WAN. MRI Application in Quantification of Epiphyseal Development in the Wrist and Bone Age Estimation of Han Male Adolescents in East China [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2024, 40(6): 589-596. |
| [9] | Hao-jie QIN, Yuan-yuan LIU, En-hao FU, Ya-wen LIU, Zhi-ling TIAN, He-wen DONG, Tai-ang LIU, Dong-hua ZOU, Yi-bin CHENG, Ning-guo LIU. Intelligent Recognition and Segmentation of Blunt Craniocerebral Injury CT Images Based on DeepLabV3+ Model [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2024, 40(5): 419-429. |
| [10] | Jing-chen GE, Min SHANG, Ming-yang YAO, Ming-fei WEI, Jun-zhan SHI, Ze-wei YAO, Jia-yin SHI, Fan LI. Application of MSCT Image Post-Processing Techniques in the Identification of Rib Fracture Malunion [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2024, 40(4): 324-329. |
| [11] | Jia-xuan HAN, Shi-hui SHEN, Yi-wen WU, Xiao-dan SUN, Tian-nan CHEN, Jiang TAO. Adolescents and Children Age Estimation Using Machine Learning Based on Pulp and Tooth Volumes on CBCT Images [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2024, 40(2): 143-148. |
| [12] | Lei SHI, Ye XUE, Li-rong QIU, Ting LU, Fei FAN, Yu-chi ZHOU, Zhen-hua DENG. Research Progress on Dental Age Estimation Based on MRI Technology [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2024, 40(2): 112-117. |
| [13] | Yu-xin GUO, Wen-qing BU, Yu TANG, Di WU, Hui YANG, Hao-tian MENG, Yu-cheng GUO. Dental Age Estimation in Northern Chinese Han Children and Adolescents Using Demirjian’s Method Combined with Machine Learning Algorithms [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2024, 40(2): 135-142. |
| [14] | Dan-yang LI, Yu PAN, Hui-ming ZHOU, Lei WAN, Cheng-tao LI, Mao-wen WANG, Ya-hui WANG. Application of Medical Statistical and Machine Learning Methods in the Age Estimation of Living Individuals [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2024, 40(2): 118-127. |
| [15] | Huai-han ZHANG, Yong-jie CAO, Ji ZHANG, Jian XIONG, Ji-wei MA, Xiao-tong YANG, Ping HUANG, Yong-gang MA. Adults Ischium Age Estimation Based on Deep Learning and 3D CT Reconstruction [J]. Journal of Forensic Medicine, 2024, 40(2): 154-163. |
| Viewed | ||||||
|
Full text |
|
|||||
|
Abstract |
|
|||||